Overall pretty good. Booked two cars for our trip and both got upgraded to a BMW X1 and an Audi Q2. They didn’t try to force any insurance on us. The only hassle was returning the car, as the area was filled with restricted zones and one-way streets, which the GPS failed to identify. We had to return to the hotel and get directions from the hotel staff to find the rental office. Make sure to ask for directions when picking up the car.

Like: I got an unbelievably low rate through easy rent cars.com and the car was almost exactly what we wanted.
Dislike: The horn in the car didn’t work and in Italy you definitely need a horn. The car company REALLY REALLY should give EVERYONE quick briefing on driving in Italy (ZTL zones, camera surveillance and ticketing, etc) even if it’s just a 3x5 size explaining in the drivers language what mostly is different in traffic laws for Italy. It could even be written by former car rental customers.